
It's about this time each football season that I love to dig into the StatFox database for both college & pro football and tabulate the Outplay Factor Ratings for each team. By now, all the clubs have at least four games in the books, meaning we have a decent idea as to how they stack up for 2009. However, as is always the case, there are teams that are overrated and teams that are underrated. The StatFox Outplay Factor Ratings can help to pinpoint such cases, as they ignore wins & losses, and rather quantify how well a team is either outplaying or being outplayed by their opponents. The big thing that the OF does for us is take into account schedule strength, as often teams are given too much credit for whipping up on bad opponents while not enough for playing a very competitive game but coming up short to an elite club.
With that in mind, here are the early season StatFox Outplay Factor Ratings for all the clubs as they headed into last weekend's games. I have sorted the teams by division or conference so you can easily compare the numbers, as the teams match up head-to-head most often. The (Off) column is the team's Offensive Outplay Factor Rating, with the higher numbers better. The (Def) column is Defensive Outplay Factor Rating, and there the lower the better. The (COF) is the Composite Outplay Factor Rating, and you can use each team's rating to generate a theoretical pointspread by comparing it to another club and then assigning home field advantage. The (RK) column indicates where that team ranks in the NFL or nationally in college. These numbers take into account ONLY 2009 game results, rather than a specific number of recent games.
Some of the things you'll want to keep an eye on as you analyze these numbers are first, any teams that may rank at or near the top of their respective division/conference in Outplay Factor Rating but not in the actual won-lost standings. These are the types of teams that may be getting undervalued by oddsmakers. Vice-versa for those teams at or near the bottom in OF, but not so in the standings. These are clubs that may be overachieving or getting the benefit of good fortune and hence ready to take a dive. The other factor that is important to consider is to find teams that are generating good offensive & defensive balance. If a team is drastically outplaying its opponents on one side of the ball and not the other, it may be a sign of a potential weak spot for that club. In other words, if a team such as San Diego has a very high offensive OF rating (positive) but also a very high positive on its defensive rating, that means it's offense is carrying the load entirely. A couple of bad or even average games by that unit and that team might be in some trouble. Same goes for a team with two very low negative numbers. That is a team that is outperforming its opponents defensively, but not getting the same performance out of its offense.
You can find out more about the StatFox Outplay Factor Rating by search the term on your favorite search engine or in the Fox Den Forum on StatFox.com.
NFL STATFOX OUTPLAY FACTOR RATINGS (as of Monday, October 12th)
AFC EAST: COF (Off, Def), Rank
NEW ENGLAND: +7.8 (Off: +4.6, Def: +-3.2) #5 of 32
NY JETS: +6.8 (Off: +-3.1, Def: +-9.9) #8 of 32
MIAMI: +4.2 (Off: +0.6, Def: +-3.6) #14 of 32
BUFFALO: +-8.8 (Off: +-5.9, Def: +2.9) #28 of 32
The AFC East has the highest combined OF of any division in the NFL thus far. Does that make it the toughest? Possibly. Even Miami had a positive rating after its first four games despite going just 1-3, meaning the Dolphins could be an underrated club in coming weeks. Both New York and New England have favorable schedules upcoming in terms of OF's, so expect these teams to continue to stay atop the division.
AFC NORTH: COF (Off, Def), Rank
CINCINNATI: +4.6 (Off: +1.2, Def: +-3.4) #12 of 32
BALTIMORE: +4.3 (Off: +4.9, Def: +0.6) #13 of 32
PITTSBURGH: +0.2 (Off: +-2, Def: +-2.2) #19 of 32
CLEVELAND: +-7.8 (Off: +-6.4, Def: +1.4) #26 of 32
The AFC North OF standings are the same as the won-lost standings, perhaps indicating that Cincinnati being atop the division is not a fluke. However, the Bengals rating of +4.6 is just 12th in the league, meaning this division as a whole in underachieving. Pittsburgh's rating is particularly alarming, since +0.2 is barely outplaying opponents, and the Steelers' final OF of '08 was +9.2. Cleveland isn't nearly as bad as some other bottom feeder teams.
AFC SOUTH: COF (Off, Def), Rank
INDIANAPOLIS: +11 (Off: +5.1, Def: +-5.9) #2 of 32
JACKSONVILLE: +-4.6 (Off: +-1.5, Def: +3.1) #22 of 32
HOUSTON: +-7 (Off: +-0.1, Def: +6.9) #25 of 32
TENNESSEE: +-8.3 (Off: +-2.7, Def: +5.6) #27 of 32
The StatFox Outplay Factor Ratings for the AFC South are a one-horse race. Oh wait, so are the actual won-lost standings. Indy has been as good as it has appeared, outplaying teams by 11.0 PPG, which is 1.8 PPG better than the #1 ranked team of '08. The other three clubs are well below the zero mark, meaning that the Colts should be favored by at least 15-points in divisional play before applying any home field points.
AFC WEST: COF (Off, Def), Rank
DENVER: +7.2 (Off: +-1.4, Def: +-8.6) #6 of 32
SAN DIEGO: +-1.3 (Off: +4.1, Def: +5.4) #20 of 32
KANSAS CITY: +-6.2 (Off: +-3.3, Def: +2.9) #24 of 32
OAKLAND: +-13.2 (Off: +-10.2, Def: +3) #31 of 32
Like the AFC South, the West also has one team in positive territory in StatFox OF headed into Week 6. Denver has won close games, and the Broncos rating of +7.2 is indicative of that. They may be 5-0, but at +7.2, should not be considered yet as a large favorite. However, according to OF ratings, there's no reason San Diego should be favored on Monday. The Chiefs are better than Oakland, despite the Raiders head-to-head win.
NFC EAST: COF (Off, Def), Rank
NY GIANTS: +8.3 (Off: +6.7, Def: +-1.6) #4 of 32
PHILADELPHIA: +5.9 (Off: +7.2, Def: +1.3) #9 of 32
DALLAS: +2.8 (Off: +3.5, Def: +0.7) #16 of 32
WASHINGTON: +-10.7 (Off: +-11.4, Def: +-0.7) #30 of 32
The NFC East is stacking up just as envisioned, with Washington bringing up the rear. However, only numbers such as the StatFox Outplay Factor Ratings can quantify just how bad the Redskins have been in their 2-3 start. At -10.7, they are 30th out of 120 teams, and with the meat of their schedule upcoming, things could get ugly for that franchise. The Giants have been good, but not at the level of New Orleans & Indy. Dallas may be the most overrated team in the NFL.
NFC NORTH: COF (Off, Def), Rank
CHICAGO: +6.9 (Off: +3.3, Def: +-3.6) #7 of 32
MINNESOTA: +4.9 (Off: +5.5, Def: +0.6) #11 of 32
GREEN BAY: +2.7 (Off: +4.8, Def: +2.1) #17 of 32
DETROIT: +-3.7 (Off: +2.6, Def: +6.3) #21 of 32
According to the StatFox OF Ratings, the NFC North is only slightly worse than the East. In fact the degree at which Detroit betters Washington explains how the Lions won their only game. In fact, Detroit should not be grouped with the truly poor teams at this point and is capable of winning games. Minnesota is easily the worst 5-0 team in football and will be tested the next three weeks. Chicago has been solid on both sides of the ball, while Green Bay needs to improve defensively.
NFC SOUTH: COF (Off, Def), Rank
NEW ORLEANS: +18.3 (Off: +13.2, Def: +-5.1) #1 of 32
ATLANTA: +8.3 (Off: +4.6, Def: +-3.7) #3 of 32
CAROLINA: +-6 (Off: +-4.1, Def: +1.9) #23 of 32
TAMPA BAY: +-10.1 (Off: +-5.4, Def: +4.7) #29 of 32
The NFC South OF ratings are as imblanced as the won-lost standings, and New Orleans is setting the pace for the entire league. The Saints will be tested this week at home vs. the Giants though. Atlanta's rout of San Francisco helped boost its rating about four points, and the Falcons are now ranked as the 3rd best team in the entire NFL. Tampa and Carolina go head-to-head Sunday, and assuming the Bucs have very little home field edge, oddsmakers have the spread pegged right, Carolina -4.
NFC WEST: COF (Off, Def), Rank
SEATTLE: +5.5 (Off: +1.4, Def: +-4.1) #10 of 32
SAN FRANCISCO: +4.1 (Off: +2.1, Def: +-2) #15 of 32
ARIZONA: +1.2 (Off: +0.4, Def: +-0.8) #18 of 32
ST LOUIS: +-17.7 (Off: +-11.9, Def: +5.8) #32 of 32
The NFC West is balanced after five weeks, just as the won-lost standings indicate. Right now, it is Seattle pacing the OF ratings, with a +5.5, putting it ahead of teams like Dallas & Minnesota. The Seahawks two shutouts help lead to a -4.1 defensive OF, 5th best in the NFL. San Francisco & Arizona are ranked lower overall than Seattle but have shown balance on both sides of the ball. St. Louis is plain awful, and according to the OF's, should be at least a 15-point dog in all divisional games.
COLLEGE FOOTBALL STATFOX OUTPLAY FACTOR RATINGS (as of Monday, October 12th)
Article by Steve Makinen of Statfox and The Platinum Sheet.